Healthy Test Kitchen
Beef Cuts
Grades of Beef
-
Prime: Highest designation, highly marbled
-
Choice: for low fat cuts, nearly indistinguishable from prime
-
Select: Much leaner than prime or choice; still tender; not as juicy or flavorful as higher grades
///////////////////////////////////////////////
Stewing Cuts of Beef
-
Chuck
-
Brisket
-
Flap meat (a.k.a. sirloin tip)- weighs 2-3 pounds
-
Round (bottom round is best; eye of round is leanest and has tendency to dry out)
-
Short Ribs- $2.79 on sale at New Grand Mart
Steak-House Cuts of Beef
-
Ribeye
-
Strip
-
Tenderloin
-
T-bone
-
Porterhouse
Butcher or Chef Cuts
-
Hanger Steak
-
Skirt Steak
-
Flank Steak
-
Short Ribs
-
Tri-Tip
-
Flap Meat (aka Sirloin Tip)
Beef Roasts
-
Rib Roast
-
Top Sirloin Roast
-
Tenderloin
-
Chuck Eye Roast
///////////////////////////////////////////////
Chuck Eye
-
Sale Price: $4.99
-
Not a lean cut of beef
-
Rich flavor similar to Rib Eye, but costs less
-
Tougher cut
-
Great for grilling or pot roasts
-
Don't cook it well done
-
Recipes
-
All American Pot Roast
-
anchovy fillets
-
Marmite (optional)
-
dry red wine
-
potatoe
-
-
Short Rib Chili with Beans
-
jalapeno
-
anchovy fillets
-
Marmite
-
ancho, pasilla, or mulato chiles
-
New Mexico red, California, costeo, or choricero chiles
-
casabel, arbol, or pequin chiles
-
28 oz crushed tomatoes
-
-
*Flat Iron Steak (a.k.a. Top Blade Steak)
-
3 out of 4 for tenderness
-
3 out of 4 for flavor
-
Ranked #2 most tender
-
Sale Price: $6.99 (Regularly priced at $7.99)
-
Grass Fed Price: $12.77
-
Not a lean cut of beef
-
Can be grilled, broiled, braised, pan fried, or marinated
-
Can be used in stir-fries, kebabs, or stews
-
Slice on the bias to serve
*Flank
-
2 out of 4 for tenderness; 7/10 for tenderness
-
3 out of 4 for flavor; 5/10 for flavor
-
Ranked #7 for tenderness
-
Price: $9.99
-
Lean cut of beef
-
Sale Price: $6.99 (Regular: $7.99)
-
Very flavorful but slightly chewy
-
Should not be cooked past medium
-
Similar to skirt steak
-
Common in fajitas and Asian stir fries
-
Slice thinly to serve
-
Grill, pan-sear, broil, or braise; most often marinated (or grilled and then cut across the grain)
-
Doesn't soak up marinades as well as hanger or skirt, but still worth marinating
-
Requires either super-slow or super-fast cook to become chewable
-
Recipes
-
Steak House Style Grilled Marinated Flank Steak
-
anchovies
-
marmite (optional)
-
fresh chives
-
shallot
-
-
Grilled Skirt Steak Fajitas
-
ancho chiles (optional)
-
guajillo chiles (optional)
-
1 each- red, yellow, green bell pepper
-
jalapeno (for pico de gallo)
-
cilantro (for pico de gallo
-
-
Beef Shwarma
-
red onion
-
garlic
-
red wine
-
tahini
-
-
Stir-Fried Beef and Broccoli with Black Bean Sauce
-
rice wine or dry sherry
-
Asian chile paste/sauce
-
fresh ginger
-
broccoli
-
green onion
-
-
Chipotle Marinated Steak
-
orange juice
-
dates
-
garlic
-
-
Beef Satay
-
fresh ginger
-
fresh garlic
-
-
Hanger Steak (8 oz each)
-
7/10 for tenderness
-
8/10 for flavor
-
pan-sear or grill to at least a medium-rare or medium
-
best cooked to medium (or to 125-130 degrees before resting) and then thinly sliced
-
high heat is relatively essential since they are thine
-
Recipes
-
Pan-Seared Hanger Steak with Herb and Garlic Marinade
-
garlic
-
fresh parsley
-
fresh thyme
-
-
Steak House Style Grilled Marinated Flank Steak
-
shallot
-
fresh chives
-
marmite (optional)
-
anchovies
-
-
Grilled Skirt Steak Fajitas
-
ancho chiles (optional)
-
guajillo chiles (optional)
-
1 each- red, yellow, green bell pepper
-
jalapeno (for pico de gallo)
-
cilantro (for pico de gallo)
-
-
Cooler-Cooked Hanger Steak with Chimichurri
-
fresh thyme
-
shallots
-
fresh parsley
-
fresh cilantro
-
fresh oregano
-
-
Skirt Steak
-
2 out of 4 for tenderness; 6/10 for tenderness
-
3 out of 4 for flavor; 7/10 for flavor
-
Ranked #10 for tenderness
-
Walmart Price: $8.62
-
$7.99 on sale at Martin's
-
Not a lean cut of beef
-
Similar to flank steak in flavor but slightly tougher
-
Especially beefy taste
-
Good option for fajitas, but can also be cooked whole
-
Grill, pan-sear, or stir-fry; absorbs marinades well but doesn't need them
-
Very thin -> High heat is essential to brown without over cooking
-
Cook over the highest heat possible from start to finish
-
Recipes
-
Steak House Style Grilled Marinated Flank Steak
-
anchovies
-
marmite (optional)
-
fresh chives
-
shallot
-
-
Grilled Skirt Steak Fajitas
-
ancho chiles (optional)
-
guajillo chiles (optional)
-
1 each- red, yellow, green bell pepper
-
jalapeno (for pico de gallo)
-
cilantro (for pico de gallo)
-
-
Stir-Fried Beef and Broccoli with Black Bean Sauce
-
garlic
-
rice wine or dry sherry
-
Asian chile paste/sauce
-
fresh ginger
-
broccoli
-
green onion
-
-
Beef Satay
-
fresh ginger
-
fresh garlic
-
-
*Tip Sirloin (a.k.a. Flap Meat)- 2-3 pounds
-
2 out of 4 for tenderness; 6/10 for tenderness
-
3 out of 4 for flavor; 6/10 for flavor
-
Sale Price: $3.99 for roast ~3 pounds (Regularly Priced $5.99)
-
Sale Price: $6.99 (Regularly Priced $8.49)
-
Walmart Price: $6.42
-
Sale Price at Aldi: $2.99-$3.99
-
Lean cut of beaf
-
More affordable than top sirloin; leaner too
-
Should be marinated before cooking because it is lean and can become dry
-
Cook: grill, pan sear, pan roast, stir fry, kebabs, or simmer in soups/stews
-
Slice thinly against the grain after cooking
-
Recipes
-
Grilled Skirt Steak Fajitas
-
ancho chiles (optional)
-
guajillo chiles (optional)
-
1 each- red, yellow, green bell pepper
-
jalapeno (for pico de gallo)
-
cilantro (for pico de gallo)
-
-
Steak House Style Grilled Marinated Flank Steak
-
anchovies
-
marmite (optional)
-
fresh chives
-
shallot
-
-
Shish Kebab
-
garlic
-
-
Sirloin Kebobs
-
mushrooms
-
red onion
-
grape tomatoes
-
-
Beef Satay
-
fresh ginger
-
fresh garlic
-
-
**Strip Steak (a.k.a. Top Sirloin, Top Loin, NY Sirloin, Shell, Sirloin Strip Steak, Sirloin Butt, Top Butt, Center-Cut Roast, Top Round First Cut, Top Round Steak Roast)
-
2-3 out of 4 for tenderness; 8/10 for tenderness
-
2-4 out of 4 for flavor; 6-7/10 for flavor
-
Ranked #3-9 for tenderness
-
Kroger Price: $11.49 or $8.49 for family pack (Sale Price: $5.99)
-
Walmart Price: $5.82-8.37 ($6.86-9.57 for choice cuts)
-
Grass Fed Price: $11.96-15.96
-
Aldi Sale Price: $4.99 for top sirloin, $5.39 or $8.49
-
very tender and juicy
-
no heavy marbling
-
lean cut of beef
-
Basically, the thick side of the T-bone
-
Pleasantly chewy texture and big beefy flavor
-
Lean, tender, and flavorful (classic steak-house cut)
-
Essentially, a T-bone steak with the tenderloin meat removed
-
Grill, pan-sear, or broil; salt/seasoning and a hot grill is all you need
-
Recipes
-
Quick and Easy Pan Seared Steaks
-
shallots
-
fresh thyme
-
-
Shish Kebab
-
garlic
-
-
Sirloin Kebabas
-
mushrooms
-
red onion
-
grape tomatoes
-
-
Mushroom Beef Skewers- mushrooms, zucchini
-
Bottom Sirloin (a.k.a. Tri-Tip)
-
5/10 for tenderness
-
4/10 for flavor
-
Less tender than top sirloin
-
Great with dry rubs and hot grills
-
Skillet, grill, broil, roast
-
Season generously and serve with flavorful sauce
Chuck Arm Steak
-
Ideal for Kebabs and Stews
-
Perfect for braising (grilling not recommended)
-
Tends to get tough
-
Recipes
-
Pressure Cooker Beef Stew
-
red wine
-
beef stock
-
potatoes
-
celery
-
-
Shoulder Steak (a.k.a. Chuck Steak)
-
2 out of 4 for tenderness
-
2 out of 4 for flavor
-
Price: $5.99
-
Walmart Price: $6.86
-
Relatively lean with a moderately beefy flavor
-
Can be a bit tough; slice thinly after cooking
-
Grill or pan-roast
Rib Eye Steak
-
3 out of 4 for tenderness; 7/10 for tenderness
-
4 out of 4 for flavor; 9/10 for flavor
-
Ranked #6 for tenderness
-
Kroger Price: $11.49 (Sale Price for Choice Value Pack: $6.99, Sale Price: $6.99-7.99, Sale Price for Choice: $8.99)
-
Walmart Price: $9.86-10.26 ($10.86-11.26 for choice cuts)
-
Sale Price for Aldi: $5.99 (roast), $9.49
-
Not a lean cut of beef
-
Essentially, a boneless piece of prime rib
-
pricey
-
remarkably juicy, rich flavor
-
tender and juicy with pronounced beefiness
-
grill, pan-sear, or broil; use a dry rub
-
Recipes
-
Quick and Easy Pan Seared Steaks
-
shallots
-
fresh thyme
-
-
Tenderloin Steak (a.k.a. Filet Mignon)
-
4 out of 4 for tenderness; 10/10 for tenderness
-
1 out of 4 for flavor; 2/10 for flavor
-
Ranked #1 most tender
-
Kroger Price: $22.99 ($9.99 sale price)
-
Walmart Price: $17.83
-
Lean cut of beef
-
Most tender and most expensive of all cuts
-
Grill, pan-sear, or broil
-
Cooks faster because it is leaner; prone to drying out
-
Grill while whole and then cut into steaks; Pair with flavorful sauces
**T-Bone Steak
-
3 out of 4 for tenderness
-
4 out of 4 for flavor
-
Ranked #5 for tenderness
-
Kroger Price: $10.49 (Kroger Sale Price: $5.99-$7.99)
-
Manager Special Price: $8.24
-
Walmart Price: $9.86-10.26 ($10.86 for choice cuts)
-
Lean cut of beaf
-
Contains bone, strip, and tenderloin
-
Grill, pan-sear, or broil (pan-searing is difficult since irregularly shaped); meat speaks for itself--just give it a dry rub
-
Position so that the tenderloin is the farthest from the heat source
Porterhouse Steak
-
3 out of 4 for tenderness
-
4 out of 4 for flavor
-
Ranked #4 for tenderness
-
Walmart Price: $11.36
-
Not a lean cut of beef
-
Essentially, just a huge T-Bone steak with a larger tenderloin section
-
Grill, pan-sear, or broil (pan searing is difficult since irregularly shaped); meat speaks for itself--just give it a dry rub
-
Position so that the tenderloin is the farthest from the heat source
Round Steak (a.k.a. Top Round, London Broil)
-
Ranked #8 for tenderness
-
Eye round, bottom round, and top round connected in a single cut
-
Top round:
-
Price: $5.99
-
one of the toughest and leanest cuts
-
popular for jerky and stew
-
braising or slow roasting; often marinated
-
Recipes
-
Pressure Cooker Beef Stew
-
garlic
-
red wine
-
beef stock
-
potatoes
-
celary
-
-
-
-
Bottom round:
-
Walmart Price: $6.24
-
requires tenderization or long cooking times to reach its peak flavor
-
lean cut of beef
-
-
Eye round steak:
-
Walmart Price: $5.96-6.99
-
lean cut of beef
-
-
I used chuck top round steak in spirals recipe. The flavor was delicious, but it was a bit tough.
Short Ribs
-
6/10 for tenderness
-
10/10 for flavor
-
High in fat, take longer to cook
-
Grill or pan-sear
-
Recipes
-
Short Rib Chili with Beans
-
jalapeno
-
anchovy fillets
-
Marmite
-
ancho, pasilla, or mulato chiles
-
New Mexico red, California, costeo, or choricero chiles
-
casabel, arbol, or pequin chiles
-
28 oz crushed tomatoes
-
-
Rib Roast (Prime Rib)
-
7/10 for tenderness
-
9/10 for flavor
-
ribs 6-9; "small end" "first cut" "loin end"; tend to be leaner
-
ribs 10-12; "large end" "chuck end" "blade end" "second cut"; chewier and slightly better flavor; includes the NY strip, rib-eye, and Delmonico steaks
-
plan on 1 pound per person
-
Sale: $8.99 (or $5.99 with coupon)
-
Recipes
-
Roasted Prime Rib
-
////
Chuck
-
5/10 for tenderness
-
6/10 for flavor
-
Walmart Price: $5.86-6.26
-
Not a lean cut of beef; High fat content
-
Flavorful and balanced
-
Extremely fatty and full of connective tissue
-
Tendency to fall apart when roasted
-
Best cooked slowly in liquid; pot roast
-
Recipes
-
All American Pot Roast with Gravy
-
anchovy fillets
-
Marmite
-
tomato paste
-
red wine
-
-
Brisket
-
Price: $6.99
-
Lean cut of beef
-
Very tough
-
Requires long, slow cooking to tenderize; pot roast
-
Recipes
-
Beef Brisket with Merlot and Prunes
-
red wine
-
prune juice
-
-
Oven Barbecued Brisket
-
Shank
-
toughest cut
-
requires long, slow cooking
-
popular cut for beef stew
Lamb Cuts
Leg of Lamb
-
New Zealant/ Australia
-
small in size
-
leg 5-6 pounds
-
grass fed
-
more gamey flavor
-
lower in fat
-
not as tender or rich
-
more affordable than American
-
-
American
-
larger, fattier, sweeter
-
grass fed but not grass finished
-
larger protective layer of fat around the legs
-
better marbling
-
richer flavor, more similar to a steak
-
juicier
-
leg can weigh ~15 pounds
-
more expensive than import
-
-
Two ends
-
shank end
-
part near the ankle
-
slightly more flavorful
-
-
sirloin end
-
part near the hip
-
fattier and more tender than the shank end
-
-
-
can be roasted
-
includes shank and sirloin
-
Boneless Lamb: $6.49 (Aldi)
-
Bone-In Lamb Leg Shank: $5.99 (Aldi)
-
Boneless Australia Lamb: $4.99 (Martins)
-
Semi-Boneless Leg Lamb: $3.99 (Martins)
-
Recipes
-
Slow Roasted Boneless Leg of Lamb with Garlic, Rosemary, and Anchovies
-
garlic
-
fresh rosemary
-
anchovy fillets
-
-
Slow Roasted Leg of Lamb with Cumin and Fennel
-
Rack of Lamb
-
good for roasting
-
$10.99
-
Recipes
-
Pan Roasted Rack of Lamb
-
fresh thyme
-
shallot
-
-
Sirloin Chop
-
inexpensive
-
can be grilled or broiled
Stew Meat/ Lamb Shoulder
-
stew meat from the shoulder is best, because it becomes very tender during braising
-
Recipes
-
Middle Eastern Lamb Stew
-
Garlic
-
Fresh spinach
-
-
Rib Chops
-
FILL IN
Square-Cut Shoulder
-
pronounced sweetness
-
less tender
-
good for slow roasting or braising
Loin Chops
-
consist of loin and tenderloin
-
leanest, tenderest, and priciest
-
good for cooking on grill or under broiler (carmelized crust and pink center)
Top Round
-
1-2 pounds
-
full flavor of tougher cuts
-
tender enough to be grilled or pan-roasted
Arm Shoulder Top
-
inexpensive
-
can be marinated and pan-fried, broiled medium-rare, or braised in red wine and herbs
Fore Shank
-
muscular bottom portion of leg
-
good for slow braises that require rich flavor, such as North African tagines
-
long cooking makes it tender
-
takes well to bright-tasting garnishes or sweet ones
Neck Slices
-
inexpensive
-
full of flavor
-
stews, braises, ragus, and other slow-cooked dishes